SOS

Insights

Fewer clicks from Google? What AI Overviews mean for local businesses

9 min read

A business owner at a desk comparing a Search Console clicks chart that is trending down with a call log that is holding steady.

AI Overviews are AI-written summaries that Google shows above the regular results, mostly for questions people type in to learn something. They reduce clicks to informational pages such as blog posts, but they trigger far less often when someone searches for a nearby business to hire. So if your website visits are down, check your leads before you assume the sky is falling: calls, forms and booked consults are the numbers that matter.

What AI Overviews are, and what they are not

Google's own documentation, "AI features and your website," describes AI Overviews and AI Mode as features that surface relevant links to help people find information quickly. Google says they are designed to appear on queries where they add something beyond what a normal search already gives.

AI Mode is the separate, conversational version. Google says both features may use a "query fan-out" technique: the system splits a question into subtopics, runs several related searches at once, and assembles one answer with links to the supporting pages.

Two things follow from that. A page can be cited without ranking first for the exact question, because the system is pulling from many sub-searches. And a person can read a complete answer without ever visiting the page that supplied it.

Which searches trigger AI Overviews

The studies agree on the broad pattern and disagree on the details, so treat every percentage below as a snapshot from one dataset, not a constant.

Informational and comparison questions

Ahrefs analyzed 146 million search result pages and reported that 99.9% of AI Overviews appeared on informational searches, meaning people trying to learn something. Seer Interactive tracked about 30,000 informational queries and found AI Overviews on roughly one in three. In its data, "X vs Y" comparisons triggered one 95.4% of the time and question-style searches 85.9% of the time.

Longer queries trigger more. WebFX studied 2.37 million queries and found AI Overviews on 54.7% of searches with seven or more words.

Examples from our three audiences:

  • "How long does a water heater last?" or "should I repair or replace my AC?"
  • "Statute of limitations for a car accident" or "LLC vs S corp for a small business"
  • "Recovery time after a facelift" or "laser hair removal vs electrolysis"

Searches where someone is ready to hire

Here the evidence is mixed. Ahrefs classified searches as local and found that only 7.9% triggered an AI Overview, against a 20.5% base rate across all keywords. WebFX found the rate fell to 6.4% when a long query included both a location and a brand name. Seer, on the other hand, reported AI Overviews on a large share of informational "near me" queries, which suggests Google is layering them on top of some local results.

Semrush tested local searches and saw cases where an AI Overview replaced the map pack with business cards. It also found that about one in five AI Overviews that shared a page with a map pack named none of the pack businesses. The practical reading: "plumber in [city]" still shows maps and listings, but "what should I look for in a plumber" may show a summary with business suggestions.

Search typeExampleAI Overview likelihood
Comparison or "vs""Botox vs filler"Very high
How-to or why question"Why is my breaker tripping"High
Cost or process question"How much does a roof replacement cost"Moderate to high
Service plus city"Estate planning attorney in Denver"Lower, per Ahrefs and WebFX
Business name"[Your firm] reviews"Low

Why blog traffic drops while leads may hold steady

Pew Research Center analyzed browsing data from 900 U.S. Google users in March 2025. When an AI summary appeared, users clicked a traditional result link in 8% of visits, versus 15% when there was no summary. They clicked a link inside the summary in only 1% of visits.

That is a real drop, but note what Pew measured: general searching, not searches for a lawyer or a roofer. The people who read "how long does a roof last" were seldom going to call you that day. The person who searches "roof repair near me" is already shopping.

This is why informational traffic often falls faster than leads. Your blog was collecting early-stage readers, and an AI summary now answers many of them. The people who need a service still have to call someone, and they do it from a map listing, a service page or a referral.

How to read Search Console honestly

Search Console is Google's free report on how your site performs in search. It can mislead you if you only watch the headline clicks line. Work through it in this order:

  1. Compare equal periods. In the Performance report, compare the last three months to the previous three months, and also to the same months last year. Seasonality (HVAC in July, tax advice in March) can look like a decline.
  2. Put impressions beside clicks. Impressions are how often your page appeared in results. If impressions are flat or rising while clicks fall, people still see you but fewer click, which is the typical AI Overview pattern. If both fall, you have a ranking problem, which is a different fix.
  3. Open the Pages tab and sort by click change. Note which pages lost the most. If they are blog posts answering general questions, that is expected. If they are your service pages or location pages, investigate.
  4. Filter queries. Use the Queries tab with a filter for words like "how," "what," "why," "vs" and "cost." Then filter for queries with your city or "near me." Compare click change between the two groups.
  5. Check the AI report, with its limits. Industry write-ups on Search Console describe a Generative AI performance report that shows impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode by page. They also note that AI clicks are counted inside the normal Web search clicks, and the report has no click or click-through rate for AI features. You can see that your pages appear, but you cannot isolate AI traffic.
  6. Compare against real leads. Put the same months next to your call log, form submissions and booked consults. If clicks are down 25% and leads are flat, you lost readers, not clients.

What to do about it

Measure leads, not traffic

Set up call tracking, form tracking and a simple count of booked consults or jobs, with the source recorded when the person books. Ask every new client how they found you, and write the answer down. A monthly one-page report of leads by source tells you more than a traffic graph.

If "ChatGPT" or "Google AI" shows up in those answers, that is a signal worth tracking, and Search Console will never show it to you.

Write pages that answer the question clearly

AI systems cite pages that state a clear answer in plain words. Put the direct answer in the first two or three sentences, then support it with specifics: your process, a typical timeline, what affects the price, when the answer changes. A generic 600-word post that repeats what ten other sites say gives an AI nothing to cite.

Google's guidance, as summarized in Search Console walkthroughs, says you do not need an llms.txt file, special formatting or a rewrite in an AI style to appear in these features. Ordinary good content and a crawlable site are the requirement. AI search optimization comes down to being the clearest, most specific source on a topic, and the same logic applies when people ask ChatGPT or Perplexity. We cover how that plays out in home services, med spas and accounting firms.

Strengthen your Google Business Profile

Semrush found that the business cards inside AI Overviews appear to draw on Google Business Profile data. Many businesses that appeared there did not have a strong website ranking, so listings, directory mentions and other sites also played a role.

Check these items, in this order:

  • Primary and secondary categories match what you actually sell
  • Services, hours, phone number and website link are complete and current
  • Name, address and phone match across your website and major directories
  • New reviews arrive steadily, and you reply to them
  • Photos are real and recent

Local SEO and Google Business Profile work is the part of your visibility that most directly produces calls.

Focus content on the services and locations people hire for

If you have limited time, put it into pages where the visitor is a buyer: one page per core service, with real detail on who it is for, what it costs or what drives the cost, what happens step by step, and proof (licenses, credentials, reviews, before and after work where rules allow). Then add location pages for cities you actually serve, with local specifics and not a swapped city name.

Service and procedure content built this way matters more than another general explainer. Our guide on writing practice area pages shows the structure, and it works for any licensed service.

Keep a few informational posts, but choose them for a reason: they answer questions your clients ask during the sale, they link to the relevant service page, and they could be cited by an AI. Stop publishing posts that exist only to chase traffic.

What a realistic plan looks like

Start with a baseline: three months of leads by source, plus the Search Console comparison above. Then decide where the gap is. If service pages are losing impressions, that is a ranking issue. If only blog clicks are falling, accept the loss and redirect effort. If leads are down, find out which channel changed before changing anything.

If you want an outside read, SEOS runs a free visibility audit that checks how you appear on Google, in Maps, and in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI answers, and reports against leads rather than clicks.

Frequently asked questions

Do AI Overviews appear for local searches like "plumber near me"?

Sometimes. Ahrefs found AI Overviews on just 7.9% of searches it classified as local, while Seer Interactive saw them on a large share of informational "near me" queries. Searches that clearly aim at hiring someone mostly still show the map pack and listings, but this is changing and varies by market.

Should I stop blogging because of AI Overviews?

No, but change what you publish. Informational posts that only restate common knowledge lose the most clicks. Posts that answer a specific buyer question, include your own process and numbers, and point to a service page can still earn citations and leads.

Can Search Console show me clicks from AI Overviews?

Not separately. Clicks from AI features are counted in the normal Web search totals, and the AI-specific report described by industry write-ups shows impressions only. You can see which pages appear, but you cannot calculate a click-through rate for AI features.

How do I know if lost clicks cost me clients?

Compare Search Console clicks with your call log, form submissions and booked consults over the same months. Add a "how did you find us" question to intake. If leads are flat while blog clicks fall, the loss is mostly early-stage readers, not buyers.

Does paying for Google Ads avoid this?

Ads sit in a different part of the page and are not affected the same way, but they cost money for every click and can be wasted just as easily. If you run ads, check that they produce booked work, as covered in the Google Ads audit and the notes above on tracking leads.

Get a free SEO and AI visibility audit.

Request a free visibility audit. We will show you which services you could be winning on Google, Maps and AI assistants, what your competitors are doing, and what it would take to be the answer.